ELXR
SYS.ONLINE--:--:--
elxr / guides / dither-ableton-export
// Guide · Max for Live

Dither in Ableton Live: which export option should you pick?

// Quick answer

Use dither only when you export at a lower bit depth than you mixed at, which in practice means 16-bit files. Pick Triangular for a safe default or POW-r for a final 16-bit master, and apply it once, on the very last export. For 24-bit or 32-bit float files, dither doesn't matter.

What dither is

Live works in 32-bit floating point inside. When you export a 16-bit file, every sample has to be rounded to one of 65,536 levels. In very quiet parts, like fade-outs and reverb tails, that rounding creates a gritty kind of distortion. Dither adds a tiny amount of noise before rounding, which turns that distortion into a very quiet, smooth hiss you won't notice.

Which option to choose

In Live's export dialog, the dither options appear when you export at a fixed bit depth:

  • No Dither: for 32-bit float files, and for 24-bit stems that will be processed further.
  • Rectangular: the lightest noise, slightly less effective. Rarely the best choice.
  • Triangular: the standard, safe choice for 16-bit files.
  • POW-r 1, 2, 3: noise-shaped dither that pushes the noise into frequencies ears hear less. Good for a final 16-bit master; POW-r 1 is the gentlest, 3 the most shaped.

Rules of thumb

  • Dither once, at the end. Dithering a file that gets dithered again later just stacks noise.
  • Stems for mixing or mastering: export 24-bit or 32-bit float without dither.
  • Final master for streaming: upload 24-bit if the distributor accepts it (no dither needed); if it must be 16-bit, use Triangular or POW-r.
  • Don't normalize after dithering. Turning the file up afterwards raises the dither noise too.

Questions

Can I hear dither?

Usually not. On a 16-bit file it sits around −90 dBFS, far below the music. You'd only hear it in near-silent fade-outs with the volume turned way up.

Do I need dither for MP3 exports?

MP3 and AAC don't use a fixed bit depth, so dither doesn't really apply. Export a 24-bit WAV and let the encoder work from that.

Should I dither 24-bit files?

It does no harm, but at 24-bit the rounding is so small it makes no audible difference.

ELXR Bundle
// Every ELXR device

ELXR Bundle

Every ELXR Max for Live device in one download. Drop any of them on a track and it works.