ELXR
SYS.ONLINE--:--:--
elxr / guides / kick-and-bass-clash-ableton
// Guide · Ableton Live

How to stop your kick and bass clashing in Ableton Live

// Quick answer

Look at the kick and the bass on the same spectrum to see which frequencies they share. Then give each one its own space: let the kick own its punch and the bass its fundamental, duck the bass when the kick hits, and tune the kick to the song's key.

Why they clash

Kick and bass both put most of their energy between about 40 and 120 Hz. When they land at the same time on the same frequencies, they add up into a boomy, muddy low end. When they're out of phase there, they partly cancel and the kick loses its punch. Either way the mix gets louder without sounding bigger.

See where your kick and bass overlap with Position →

Find the overlap first

Guessing with an EQ is slow. Put a spectrum on each track and compare them: the kick usually has a peak for its body (often 50–80 Hz) and a click higher up, the bass has a peak at its lowest notes. Where both peak at once, they fight.

Live's Spectrum shows one track at a time, so you end up switching between two windows. It's easier to see both at once on top of each other, in different colors.

Four ways to fix it

1. Duck the bass on every kick

Sidechain compression or volume shaping turns the bass down for a moment on each kick, so the kick hits clean. Our guide to sidechaining without a compressor shows the shaping way.

2. Carve with EQ

Choose who owns the lowest octave. If the kick has the deepest weight, cut the bass a little at the kick's peak with EQ Eight; if the bass carries the bottom, high-pass the kick a touch and let its punch sit above.

3. Tune the kick

A kick has a pitch. Tune it to the root or the fifth of the song's key in Simpler or Drum Rack, and it sits with the bass instead of against it.

4. Shorten one of them

A shorter kick tail or a bass note that starts just after the kick leaves each one its own moment in time.

Step by step with Position

  1. Put Position on the bass track.
  2. Add the kick track as a Source. It shows on top of the bass in its own color, without being mixed into your output.
  3. Switch to Spectrum and play. Where the two colors pile up at the same frequency, that's the clash.
  4. Switch to the Oscilloscope and lock it to 1/4 or 1 bar, so you can see whether the bass is still loud right where each kick lands.
  5. Apply one of the fixes above and watch the overlap shrink. Click a band to hear just that range while you work.
// In Position

What it looks like

Position: Up to 10 Sources
04

Up to 10 Sources

Show other tracks in their own colours on top of yours, without mixing them into your output.

Position: Spot clashes
05

Spot clashes

On the Spectrum and Oscilloscope, see exactly where your kick and bass fight. The Oscilloscope locks to your song, 1/16 to 4 bars.

Position: Spectrum and Spectrogram
03

Spectrum and Spectrogram

A live glowing spectrum, and frequency over time. Click any band to hear it on its own; click again for the full mix.

Questions

Should the kick or the bass be lower?

Either works, but pick one. In most electronic music the sub bass owns the lowest octave and the kick's punch sits just above it; in some styles a deep 808-style kick owns the bottom and the bass sits higher.

Is sidechain compression enough on its own?

It helps a lot, but if the two still share a big peak at the same frequency, a small EQ cut or retuning the kick cleans up what ducking can't.

What about an 808 that is both kick and bass?

Then there's nothing to clash with: the 808 is the low end. Make sure other sounds like pads and synths aren't adding their own lows underneath it.

Position device in Ableton Live
// The quick way

Position

See where every sound sits: left or right, wide or narrow, in phase or fighting itself, and at which frequencies.

// ELXR Bundle · save $61
All 12 devices for $69 $130 →
Add the other 11 devices for $59.